New The Lighthouse trailer asks WHAT!?

Threatening Guy Maddin’s Brand Upon the Brain title of Best Oddball Lighthouse Movie That Looks Like It Was Made a Century Ago, Robert Eggers’ (The Witch) The Lighthouse is an unconventional two-hander that sees Willem Dafoe and Robert Pattinson isolated and absolutely losing their shit. As seen in this new trailer, that includes the pair yelling “what?” at each other with increasing furor. If that were the entire movie, it would probably still get like a B, B-. That there’s more to it is just the icing on this delicious-looking black-and-white cookie.

We’ll see how all those non-“what!?” scenes play out when the film hits theaters October 18.

Please help these sad nobodies and: